Aid for Mobility: Determining When Crutches or Cane Are More Suitable

Aid for Mobility: Determining When Crutches or Cane Are More Suitable

Struggling with age, disability, or mobility challenges? Walking aids like canes and walkers can lend a hand, offering support and independence. Picking the perfect one for your unique situation requires understanding their pros, cons, and when to use them.

Navigating the dance of age means confronting impaired mobility, an unfortunately common occurrence. Falls, especially in older adult years, can lead to severe injuries. But with assistive mobility devices, we can reduce the risk, stay independent, and even recover quicker. Canes and walkers are top choices for those tackling mobility issues, yet choosing between them can be tricky. Below, we'll break down the difference between canes and walkers, and provide insights on when and how to use them.

Canes vs. Walkers: A Comparison

The Medical Lowdown: When Do Canes & Walkers Come In Handy?

-helps with balance-adjustable

Canes and walkers bolster stability during mobility. Canes lend a helping hand to those with minor balance or stability issues, weak legs, or injuries from conditions like arthritis.

-for minimal weight bearing only-some have a curved handle that some may find difficult to grasp and cause pain, especially for people with joint or muscle conditions

A typical cane-user grips the cane with one hand and adjusts it to accommodate different terrains or needs. A multi-legged cane can be a better match for those with more significant pain on one side, offering a wider, more stable base.

-mild balance issues-mild to moderate arthritis of the lower limbs

A person who experiences profound balance and mobility issues may find a walker more suited. Walkers, four-legged devices that require both hands, are suitable for those with one-sided muscle weakness, or individuals recovering from total knee or hip replacement surgery. To customize a walker for comfort, users can add wrist or arm supports and various accessories like wheels or brakes.

$10-$40

Types of Canes and Walkers

-offers greater help with balance than a standard cane-can bear more weight-adjustable

Standard canes, popular for those needing minimal help, are typically made from wood or aluminum, with a rubber tip and a hook-shaped or flat handle. While sufficient for minor assistance, they're not ideal for those requiring more substantial support.

-heavier-more cumbersome-may be harder to use on stairs

Multi-legged canes—known for their greater stability—come in 3 or 4 legs. These canes can stand independently, making them the right choice for those with pain on one side. "Sit-to-stand" canes are an option too, offering extra support when getting up or sitting down.

-one-sided muscle weakness (hemiparesis) or more significant issues with balance

Three types of walkers cater to different needs: the standard walker, two-wheeled walker, and four-wheeled walker (rollator).

$15-$40

• The standard walker is the most stable, with four rubber-tipped legs. Users must lift it with each step.
• The two-wheeled walker makes navigation easier but is less stable and requires more cognitive effort.
• The four-wheeled walker (rollator) retains mobility with brakes, a seat, and a basket, but requires more coordination and can be heavier to maneuver.

-stable-foldable

The Bigger Picture: Canes vs. Walkers

-no wheels-needs lifting with each step

Using a cane demands sufficient strength and balance, and it should accompany steady, secure steps. While canes can help with minor balance troubles, users must have the ability to steady themselves if they lose their balance. They must also coordinate their cane with their stride.

-for conditions that affect the function of muscles or nerves or for fractures

Walkers are a better option for those with more severe balance issues. Walkers enable users to shift some or all of their body weight away from their lower body while moving—an essential advantage. When using a walker, users benefit from the added support their arms can provide. As their endurance and strength improve, they can prioritize putting more weight on their legs.

$20-$60

Whether to use a walker with or without wheels is contingent on where it will primarily be used. For home-bound individuals, a four-wheeled walker can do the trick. For outdoor navigation, a two-wheeled walker works best, thanks to its ease of navigation through different terrains.

-easier to move-may have a seat and basket for comfort

Making the Right Move: switch from a walker to a cane

-less stable than standard-not foldable

The decision to swap from a walker to a cane or vice versa involves distinct considerations. Asking yourself the following questions can help you make the right call:

-issues affecting the spinal cord, conditions that slow down mobility like heart or lung diseases

• Has my or my loved one's balance improved or worsened?
• Has my or my loved one's endurance and strength improved or worsened?
• What does the doctor recommend?
• Is my or my loved one's daily routine more appropriate for a walker or a cane?

$35-$100

Obtaining Your Helping Hand: Sources for Canes and Walkers

If you're in the market for a cane or walker, you can purchase one directly from a supplier. You may also be able to acquire one from a clinic or hospital, your insurance company, or a non-profit organization for older adults or individuals with disabilities.

The Cost Difference: Canes vs. Walkers

According to American Family Physician, canes usually cost between $10 and $40, while walkers range from $20 to $100.

Navigating the Adventure Ahead: Medicare and Mobility Aids

Medicare considers walkers and canes as Durable Medical Equipment (DME). If your doctor recommends a cane or a walker for home use and deems it medically necessary, you can rent or purchase one through Medicare Part B. A doctor accepting Medicare must be the one to write the prescription, and the device must come from a Medicare-approved supplier.

Savoring Success: Safe and Sound Mobility

Regardless of your choice, ensures your device's handle is at wrist level with relaxed arms, and keep your arms slightly bent while using it. For canes, hold the cane with the opposite hand from the injured or painful side. When going up or down stairs, avoid using the cane to help stand or balance; instead, enlist the help of a handrail.

Walker-users, plant the walker one step ahead and move your injured or painful leg to the middle before bringing your stronger leg forward. When sitting or standing, sit/stand slowly to preserve your balance and ensure your safety.

1. Canes and walkers are valuable mobility aids for those tackling balance and mobility issues, often caused by age, disability, or chronic diseases.
2. A standard cane can offer support for minor balance or stability concerns, while multi-legged canes can provide greater stability for individuals with one-sided muscle weakness or more significant balance issues.
3. Walkers are an effective solution for those with severe balance problems, as they allow users to shift weight away from their lower body and offer additional support from the arms.
4. The choice between canes and walkers can be affected by specific medical conditions, such as arthritis, muscle or nerve disorders, or fractures.
5. Navigating outdoor environments may require a two-wheeled walker, while home-bound individuals might find a four-wheeled walker more suitable.
6. Regarding cost, canes typically range from $10 to $40, while walkers can cost from $20 to $100.
7. Medicare can cover the cost of mobility aids like canes and walkers, providing they are deemed medically necessary and the prescription comes from a doctor accepting Medicare.
8. Safety should always be prioritized when using mobility aids, with proper techniques such as keeping the device handle at wrist level, using the opposite hand for a cane, and moving deliberately with a walker.

Read also: