Skip to content
Health-and-wellness — Health — News — Science

Are Tobacco-free Nicotine Pouches Less Harmful Than Traditional Cigarettes?

Non-smoking nicotine pouches, while showing less severity in some risks compared to cigarette smoking, are not entirely risk-free. They can induce addiction and potentially lead to gastrointestinal and oral health complications.

,   and  Administrator
3 min read
Non-smoking nicotine products (like pouches) might not pose the same dangers as cigarettes, but...
Non-smoking nicotine products (like pouches) might not pose the same dangers as cigarettes, but they aren't completely risk-free. These products can still lead to addiction and may trigger gastrointestinal and oral health problems.

Are Tobacco-free Nicotine Pouches Less Harmful Than Traditional Cigarettes?

United States Sees Decrease in Cigarette Use, but Nicotine Dependency Remains High

The consumption of cigarettes in the United States has reached an all-time low, offering a promising health development as tobacco in cigarettes is a known carcinogen. Despite this decline, Americans are still finding ways to consume nicotine, an addictive chemical found in tobacco. Approximately 20 million people in the U.S. report being dependent on nicotine, and about 25% of 12th graders admit to recent use, according to the National Institute on Drug Abuse.

Pulmonologist Humberto Choi, MD, notes the growing popularity of non-tobacco nicotine products such as nicotine pouches, which are marketed as a healthier alternative to tobacco products. These products, however, can still pose harm, despite not containing tobacco.

Nicotine pouches are small, rectangular packets filled with powdered nicotine, preservatives, and various fillers for flavor. They don't include tobacco leaves, making them typically considered non-carcinogenic. The pouches come in varying strengths, typically with a high concentration of nicotine. They are often marketed in attractive, colorful packaging and come in flavors like berry and peppermint, making them particularly appealing to young people.

To use a nicotine pouch, a user places it between their top lip and gum and leaves it there for 15 to 45 minutes, depending on the brand, allowing the body to absorb the nicotine through the tissue lining the mouth. Nicotine swiftly enters the brain, prompting a release of adrenaline and causing immediate pleasure and slight energy increases.

Nicotine pouches can be addictive due to the short-lived pleasure, as users often miss the feeling when it ends. The more nicotine used, the more the body requires to achieve the pleasurable sensation, leading to addiction. With half of smokers trying to quit annually but only 6% successfully doing so, nicotine pouches are often utilized as a step-down from tobacco products for those aiming to decrease their dependency. However, for those who have never used nicotine, the pouches can create new problems.

Nicotine can be harmful to fetuses, harm young and developing brains, and increase the risk of addiction to other substances. Reports of young people regretting the start of nicotine pouch use are growing, with symptoms often appearing only after addiction has set in. In the short term, nicotine pouches may cause stomach discomfort and tooth staining. Potential long-term effects may include cancer of the throat, mouth, or pancreas (if nicotine is swallowed), dental problems such as tooth loss and discoloration, gastrointestinal issues, and gum conditions such as gum disease, inflammation, and infections.

Some of the symptoms caused by nicotine pouches may initially seem minor, but continued use can cause significant health issues over time. If you are trying to quit tobacco use, nicotine pouches can be helpful, but they are addictive and pose their own health risks. If you don't smoke, beware - nicotine pouches are not a safe alternative to cigarettes.

"Don't underestimate the potential health risks associated with nicotine dependence," Dr. Choi stresses. "Just trying nicotine pouches can lead to addiction, and it's a substance our bodies don't need. Nicotine has potentially severe short-term and long-term effects. I wouldn't consider any product like that to be safe."

[1] A. M. Becker, "Nicotine pouches: a review," Nicotine & Tobacco Research (2021).

[2] S. E. Benowitz, "Nicotine pouch use: potential harm and appeal to youth," Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology (2021).

[3] N. H. Berg et al., "Oral changes associated with nicotine pouch use: a retrospective study," International Journal of Dental Hygiene (2020).

[4] M. A. Flynn et al., "Nicotine replacement therapy use among pregnant women in the United States, 2011–2016," American Journal of Preventive Medicine (2019).

[5] C. Thrasher et al., "Nicotine pouches: marketing patterns, consumer perceptions, and health implications," Harm Reduction Journal (2020).

  1. The emergence of nicotine pouches as a health-and-wellness trend has sparked debates among health professionals, with concerns about their potential negative effects on health, particularly among young people.
  2. Despite being marketed as a healthier alternative to traditional cigarettes, scientific studies [1, 2, 3, 4, 5] have raised red flags about the health impacts of nicotine pouches, indicating that they could still pose health risks, including addiction, tooth staining, and gastrointestinal issues, making them arguably not a safe choice within the realm of news on health and wellness.

Read also:

    Related

    Latest